Get Free Ebook Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis and a Review of the Evidence, by Paul E Meehl
You may not should be question regarding this Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl It is simple method to obtain this publication Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl You could simply see the established with the link that we supply. Right here, you could purchase guide Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl by on the internet. By downloading and install Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl, you could locate the soft documents of this publication. This is the exact time for you to start reading. Even this is not printed book Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl; it will specifically offer more benefits. Why? You might not bring the published publication Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl or pile the book in your house or the workplace.
Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis and a Review of the Evidence, by Paul E Meehl
Get Free Ebook Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis and a Review of the Evidence, by Paul E Meehl
Why must get ready for some days to get or get guide Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl that you get? Why need to you take it if you can get Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl the much faster one? You can locate the exact same book that you buy here. This is it guide Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl that you can receive straight after purchasing. This Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl is popular book worldwide, naturally many individuals will certainly try to possess it. Why don't you end up being the initial? Still puzzled with the method?
Checking out book Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl, nowadays, will certainly not compel you to always get in the store off-line. There is a terrific area to buy the book Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl by on the internet. This internet site is the best site with lots varieties of book collections. As this Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl will certainly remain in this book, all publications that you require will certainly be right here, too. Merely hunt for the name or title of the book Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl You can find what exactly you are hunting for.
So, even you need obligation from the firm, you could not be puzzled more considering that books Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl will consistently assist you. If this Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl is your ideal partner today to cover your work or work, you could as quickly as feasible get this book. Exactly how? As we have actually informed formerly, merely check out the web link that we provide below. The final thought is not only the book Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl that you search for; it is how you will certainly get lots of publications to support your ability and capability to have great performance.
We will reveal you the best and best method to obtain book Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl in this world. Bunches of compilations that will certainly sustain your task will be here. It will make you really feel so perfect to be part of this web site. Becoming the participant to consistently see exactly what up-to-date from this book Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl website will certainly make you feel best to hunt for guides. So, recently, and also here, get this Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis And A Review Of The Evidence, By Paul E Meehl to download and install and wait for your valuable worthwhile.
Clinical versus Statistical Prediction is Paul Meehl's famous examination of benefits and disutilities related to the different ways of combining information to make predictions. It is a clarifying analysis as relevant today as when it first appeared.
A major methodological problem for clinical psychology concerns the relation between clinical and actuarial methods of arriving at diagnoses and predicting behavior. Without prejudging the question as to whether these methods are fundamentally different, we can at least set forth the obvious distinctions between them in practical applications. The problem is to predict how a person is going to behave: What is the most accurate way to go about this task?
Clinical versus Statistical Prediction offers a penetrating and thorough look at the pros and cons of human judgment versus actuarial integration of information as applied to the prediction problem. Widely considered the leading text on the subject, Paul Meehl's landmark analysis is reprinted here in its entirety, including his updated preface written forty-two years after the first publication of the book.
This classic work is a must-have for students and practitioners interested in better understanding human behavior, for anyone wanting to make the most accurate decisions from all sorts of data, and for those interested in the ethics and intricacies of prediction. As Meehl puts it, "When one is dealing with human lives and life opportunities, it is immoral to adopt a mode of decision-making which has been demonstrated repeatedly to be either inferior in success rate or, when equal, costlier to the client or the taxpayer."
- Sales Rank: #3106600 in Books
- Published on: 2015-09-10
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.25" h x .44" w x 7.52" l, 1.10 pounds
- Binding: Hardcover
- 164 pages
Most helpful customer reviews
15 of 15 people found the following review helpful.
Definitive treatment of clinical prediction
By J. Ruscio
More than half a century after its original publication in 1954, this remains the most important scholarly work on this subject. As Meehl noted in this monograph and elsewhere, he most emphatically was not comparing different ways of gathering information (e.g., tests vs. interviews). Rather, he was comparing different ways of integrating whatever information has been gathered to make the most valid predictions possible, and thereby to use the most ethically defensible decision-making procedure. One could gather the information through tests (standardized, projective, etc.), interviews (structured, unstructured, or semi-structured), archival records (school, medical, criminal, etc.), informants (family, coworkers, etc.), and a number of other ways.
Meehl's analysis dealt with how all of this information is combined. Should we do it in our heads, or should we use a mechanical decision aid, such as an equation or an actuarial table? He presented a sophisticated analysis of the task and considered conditions that might favor each approach. In one chapter, he reviewed the available empirical data, but this is not the focal point of this monograph.
An article by Grove and Meehl (1996) provides an excellent treatment of objections to mechanical decision aids, with persuasive rebuttals for each, and a meta-analysis by Grove et al (2000) provide a quantitative review of the empirical literature on the subject, including 136 studies that met fairly strict inclusion criteria (in contrast to the 20 studies that were available to Meehl for review in 1954).
Meehl's original conclusion that mechanical decision aids achieve validity rates equal or superior to those of experts exercising their unaided judgment has stood the test of time and is now supported by such a large and diverse array of studies that an impartial reader can reasonably conclude that this "controversy" has been settled.
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful.
Importance of Meehl's "little book"
By Loyd
This is probably one of the most important books ever written (early 50's), and as a result widely ignored by fields that relied (or rely) upon subjective judgements such as medicine. The last time I read anything about this issue, there had not been one study that contradicted Meehl's basic findings (see for example, work by Hastie and Dawes). Yet, irrational decision making is pervasive. Years ago I went through medical school and a psychiatry residency without one reference to this book. I had to find this on my own, and fortunately did so in the late 70's. This and issues such as construct validity, improper linear models, and at least the idea of Bayesian statistics got me into a lot of trouble with my fellow workers in mental health who made totally irrational clinical decisions seriously harming many people (I worked in public mental health centers for the most part); so ultimately Meehl was responsible for my ending a very frustrating career in public psychiatry. Long story. People always tell me I should write a book. Of all the things I studied for many years, Meehl was the foundation.
14 of 19 people found the following review helpful.
An analysis of interviews VS psychological tests
By Amazon Customer
Despite the ago of this book (written around 1954 as an expansion of lectures given in the years 1947-1950, fifth printing (unchanged) in 1963), the points raised by Paul Meehl remain current.
Paul Meehl asks himself the question what "how can we predict how a person is going to behave?". He distinguishes 2 main approaches: clinical interviews VS statistics (psychometric tests) and discusses the pros and cons of both approaches.
For decades psychologists have been struggling between the use of tests (statistics) and (clinical) interviews. I ran into the problem myself when I did a Whiplash study in 1999 and found that many doctors made clear mistakes during the patient's LAB Profile interviews, to such an extend that the produced data was unreliable for further research! Since then, I reluctantly moved over to the testing side and co-developed the iWAM test (see jobEQ.com), but I recommend complementing tests with structured follow up interviews to check the validity of the test answers.
One of his main points pro testing is that "Every hour a clinician spends in thinking and talking about whom to treat, and how and how long, is being subtracted from the available pool of therapeutic time itself." The main counter argument of a clinician will be that every individual is a separate case and thus becomes hard to find in the numbers.
In global, one can say that Meehl holds a quite impartial point of view and tries to present approaches in a factual manner, trying to bring them together. A slight bias towards testing may be expected, given that Paul Meehl was a professor of Psychology and psychiatry at the University of Minnesota and also wrote a book on the clinical use of MMPI.
Complementary books you may what to read are "Psychological testing" by Kaplan & Saccuzzo (2001) and "How to think straight about psychology" by Stanovich, 2001
Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis and a Review of the Evidence, by Paul E Meehl PDF
Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis and a Review of the Evidence, by Paul E Meehl EPub
Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis and a Review of the Evidence, by Paul E Meehl Doc
Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis and a Review of the Evidence, by Paul E Meehl iBooks
Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis and a Review of the Evidence, by Paul E Meehl rtf
Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis and a Review of the Evidence, by Paul E Meehl Mobipocket
Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis and a Review of the Evidence, by Paul E Meehl Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar